Thinking about safety? Don't think about a small pickup if that's the case. If you've got a Chevy Colorado/Canyon, you might want to consider upping your life insurance policy.
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) recently performed their first side impact tests on five of the most popular small pickups and for all but one, the results were nothing to brag about. In this day and age, most manufacturers should hide their heads in shame.
Point Number 1: The IIHS only has three grades for its tests; Good, Marginal, and Poor.
Point Number 2: The five trucks tested were the Dakota, Ranger, Frontier, Colorado/Canyon, and Tacoma.
Point Number 3: The Ranger, which has been around since the K car, did better than the Colorado.
Point Number 4: According to the IIHS, small pickups have the highest driver death rate of any vehicle on the road. Let me repeat that;
small pickups have the highest driver death rate of any vehicle on the road.
Okay, so here's the scenario: it's a side impact test where the truck is stationary and a moving barrier with a deformable front end (representing the front of a pickup or SUV) strikes the pickup on the driver's side at a 90 degree angle at 50 kph (31 mph). Two important matters to bring to your attention (especially if you own, or are considering owning, a Colorado), the height of the barrier is below the heads of the dummies and the tests do not assess the risks of head injury from side impacts for SUVs and pickups. Now stop and reread this paragraph; that last sentence is really important, especially if you look back at Point Number 4.
So that basically is the test. One thing to add to this and that is that if side airbags are an
option, the IIHS will, as a rule, test a vehicle without them unless the automaker wants to rerun the test with them and is willing to pay the cost of the vehicle to be crashed. The Ranger doesn't offer side airbags (it's the only one that doesn't), the Tacoma has them as standard equipment, but surprisingly, none of the other three automakers requested a test with airbags.
So let's take a look at how they performed. They only truck to get a Good rating was the Toyota Tacoma; the only one with side airbags offered as standard equipment. The Dakota, Ranger, and Frontier all squeaked by with a Marginal rating. The Colorado was the only one to get a Poor rating. Why? Well, remember when I mentioned about the height of the barrier and that they don't assess head injuries? This is where it all ties together. The dummy's head in the Colorado actually came in contact with the moving barrier during the crash. The barrier was lower and outside the vehicle and the dummy's head came in contact with it. Take a minute and work on that visual image for awhile. Think about the forces on the dummy's neck but don't think about it too long if you own one of these vehicles.
So what can we learn from this? Well, here's my summary of today's class:
Lesson 1: Don't buy a small pickup if you're concerned about safety.
Lesson 2: If you are concerned about safety, cough up the bucks for the side airbags. Feel free to berate the dealer for not having them as standard equipment ... that is, unless you're at the Toyota dealership.
Lesson 3: Don't buy a Colorado unless you're Chuck Norris.
In their press release, issued today, July 24, the IIHS stated that the crash worthiness for all but the Tacoma was "dismal" and that "most small pickups aren't good choices for people looking for safe transportation."
In case you're wondering about your chances of having a side impact crash, they are the second most common type of fatal crash, killing close to 9,000 people in the U.S. in 2006.